Skip to main content

Mohammed Sultan

Communitarianism vs Liberalism

Are we primarily free individuals who choose our own values, or members of communities whose traditions shape who we are? In the 1980s, this question sparked one of the most important debates in contemporary political philosophy: the liberal–communitarian debate. On one side stood liberals such as John Rawls, who emphasized individual rights and state neutrality. On the other stood communitarians such as Michael Sandel, Alasdair MacIntyre, Charles Taylor and Michael Walzer, who argued that liberalism misunderstands the self and neglects the common good. This article explains the main positions and why the debate still matters.

In short: liberalism, in its modern Rawlsian form, holds that individuals have rights that cannot be sacrificed for collective goals and that the state should remain neutral among competing conceptions of the good life. Communitarians reply that people are not “unencumbered selves” but are shaped by their families, cultures, religions and nations; that justice cannot be separated from shared understandings of the good; and that excessive individualism weakens social bonds. Today, most thinkers accept elements of both views, debating how to balance individual rights with community and shared values.

The liberal starting point: Rawls

The debate began as a response to John Rawls’s A Theory of Justice (1971). Rawls asked what principles of justice people would choose if they were placed behind a “veil of ignorance,” not knowing their social position, talents or personal values. He argued that they would choose equal basic liberties for all and arrangements that benefit the least advantaged. Central to Rawls’s view is the “priority of the right over the good”: principles of justice should not depend on any particular vision of the good life, so that people with different religions and philosophies can live together fairly.

The communitarian critique

Michael Sandel: the unencumbered self

In Liberalism and the Limits of Justice (1982), Michael Sandel argued that Rawls’s theory relies on an implausible picture of the self: an “unencumbered self” that exists prior to its ends and attachments and can choose them freely. In reality, Sandel claimed, we are partly constituted by our commitments, as members of families, communities, nations and peoples. These attachments are not simply chosen; they are part of who we are.

Alasdair MacIntyre: virtue and tradition

In After Virtue (1981), Alasdair MacIntyre argued that modern moral discourse is fragmented because it has lost the framework of tradition and virtue that once gave it meaning. Drawing on Aristotle, he insisted that moral reasoning takes place within traditions and practices, and that human life has the unity of a narrative.

Charles Taylor and Michael Walzer

Charles Taylor, in Sources of the Self (1989), showed how modern identity grew out of particular cultural and religious histories, and criticized “atomism,” the view that individuals are self-sufficient outside society. Michael Walzer, in Spheres of Justice (1983), argued that goods such as health care, education, money and political office have different social meanings, so justice must respect the distinct criteria of each sphere rather than apply a single abstract formula.

IssueLiberal viewCommunitarian view
The selfIndividuals can choose and revise their endsIndividuals are shaped by communities and traditions
Right and goodJustice should be neutral among conceptions of the goodJustice depends on shared understandings of the good
Role of the stateProtect rights and fair rules, not promote a way of lifeSupport the common good and institutions of community
Main dangerOppression of individuals by majorities or authoritiesIsolation, loss of solidarity and civic decline
Key thinkersJohn Rawls, Ronald Dworkin, Will KymlickaMichael Sandel, Alasdair MacIntyre, Charles Taylor, Michael Walzer

The liberal response

Liberals answered in several ways. Rawls himself, in Political Liberalism (1993), clarified that his theory was “political, not metaphysical”: it did not claim that people are unencumbered in their personal lives, only that citizens in a diverse society need shared principles that do not depend on any single comprehensive doctrine. Will Kymlicka argued that liberals can value culture and community precisely because they provide the context in which individuals make meaningful choices. Others warned that appeals to community can justify the oppression of minorities or dissenters.

Beyond the debate

  • Responsive communitarianism: Amitai Etzioni and others developed a public-policy communitarianism seeking a balance between rights and responsibilities.
  • Social capital: Robert Putnam’s work on the decline of community life gave empirical weight to communitarian concerns, as discussed in our article on civil society.
  • Multiculturalism: the debate shaped discussions about minority rights and cultural recognition.
  • Religion and public life: it also raised questions about the role of religious traditions in shaping moral and civic life.

Conclusion

The liberal–communitarian debate is not simply an academic quarrel. It concerns how we understand ourselves and what we owe to one another. Liberals remind us of the dignity and freedom of the individual; communitarians remind us that individuals flourish only within communities, traditions and shared goods. To continue, read our articles on the state and civil society, natural law and browse the political theory section. Arabic readers may enjoy our article Is Individualism Freedom or Isolation?

References

  • John Rawls, A Theory of Justice, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1971.
  • Michael J. Sandel, Liberalism and the Limits of Justice, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1982.
  • Alasdair MacIntyre, After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory, London: Duckworth, 1981.
  • Charles Taylor, Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1989.
  • Stephen Mulhall and Adam Swift, Liberals and Communitarians, 2nd ed., Oxford: Blackwell, 1996.

Share this article

WhatsApp
Telegram
X
Facebook
LinkedIn
Enjoyed this article?Join 40K+ subscribers on YouTube and 20K+ followers on Facebook, where I explain these ideas and more on video (in Arabic).
Subscribe on YouTube
Follow me:
Picture of Mohammed Sultan

Mohammed Sultan

Political theory researcher and Latin America expert. He writes on political thought, civilizations and the critique of modernity, combining careful research with more than 13 years of creative and marketing experience.

Sultan's Monthly Letter

One selected article, my latest videos and readings in political theory and Latin America: one email a month, no spam.

Your email is safe. Unsubscribe anytime.

Related articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *