Skip to main content

Mohammed Sultan

Natural Law: From Aquinas to Locke

Is there a law above the laws made by kings and parliaments? Can a law be legal and yet unjust? For more than two thousand years, thinkers in the natural law tradition have answered yes: there are moral principles rooted in human nature and accessible to reason that every just legal order must respect. This idea shaped medieval theology, early modern international law and the language of natural rights that inspired modern constitutions. This article traces natural law theory from its ancient roots through Thomas Aquinas to John Locke, and explains the main criticisms it has faced.

In short: natural law theory holds that there are objective moral principles, knowable by human reason, which provide the standard for judging human laws. Its roots lie in Greek philosophy and Roman Stoicism. Thomas Aquinas gave it its classic form in the 13th century, distinguishing eternal, natural, human and divine law. In the 17th century Hugo Grotius applied it to relations between states, and John Locke derived from it natural rights to life, liberty and property that government exists to protect. Legal positivists such as Bentham and Austin later rejected the idea that law depends on morality.

Ancient roots

The idea that some laws are higher than the commands of rulers appears early in Greek thought. In Sophocles’ tragedy Antigone, the heroine defies the king’s decree by appealing to the “unwritten and unfailing” laws of the gods. Aristotle distinguished between what is just by nature and what is just merely by convention. The Stoics went further, teaching that the whole universe is governed by divine reason (logos) and that human beings, as rational creatures, share in this universal law.

The Roman statesman Cicero gave the idea its most famous ancient formulation in On the Republic: true law is right reason in agreement with nature, universal, unchanging and eternal, the same in Rome and in Athens. Roman jurists later spoke of a ius naturale common to all peoples.

Thomas Aquinas: the classic synthesis

The Dominican theologian Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) built the most influential account of natural law in his Summa Theologiae (I–II, questions 90–97). He defined law as an ordinance of reason for the common good, made by whoever has care of the community, and promulgated. He then distinguished four kinds of law:

Type of lawAquinas’s meaning
Eternal lawGod’s rational plan governing the whole of creation
Natural lawThe participation of rational creatures in the eternal law, known through reason
Human lawParticular rules made by human authorities by applying natural law to concrete circumstances
Divine lawRevealed law of Scripture, which guides human beings toward their final end

For Aquinas, the first precept of natural law is that “good is to be done and pursued, and evil avoided.” From this follow precepts based on natural human inclinations: to preserve life, to raise children, to know the truth and to live in society. Human laws derive their authority from natural law. A human law that contradicts it, Aquinas argued, is “no longer a law but a perversion of law,” although he also advised caution about disobedience when it would cause scandal or disorder.

From Salamanca to Grotius

In the 16th century, Spanish theologians of the School of Salamanca, such as Francisco de Vitoria and Francisco Suárez, used natural law to debate the rights of the Indigenous peoples of the Americas and the justice of war. Vitoria argued that the Indigenous peoples possessed genuine dominion over their lands and could not be dispossessed simply because they were not Christian.

The Dutch jurist Hugo Grotius, in On the Law of War and Peace (1625), made natural law the foundation of international law. In a famous passage he claimed that natural law would retain some validity “even if we were to concede” that God did not exist, a phrase later read as a step toward a more secular understanding of natural law. Grotius is often called the father of international law.

Hobbes and Locke: natural law becomes natural rights

In the 17th century, the focus shifted from natural law as a set of duties to natural rights belonging to individuals. Thomas Hobbes spoke of “laws of nature,” but understood them as rational rules for self-preservation that become effective only under a sovereign power.

John Locke, in his Second Treatise of Government (1689), gave natural law a very different political meaning. Even in the state of nature, he argued, people are governed by a law of nature, which teaches that “no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions.” People create government by consent in order to protect these rights more securely. If a government systematically violates them, the people may resist and establish a new one. Locke’s ideas deeply influenced the American Declaration of Independence of 1776, with its appeal to “unalienable Rights” to “Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”

Criticisms and revival

  • The is–ought problem: David Hume argued that we cannot logically derive moral conclusions (“ought”) from facts about nature (“is”).
  • Legal positivism: Jeremy Bentham dismissed natural rights as “nonsense upon stilts,” and John Austin defined law as the command of a sovereign, independent of its moral merit. In the 20th century, H. L. A. Hart refined the positivist view that law and morality are conceptually separate.
  • Cultural diversity: critics asked whether a universal moral law can be identified amid the variety of human customs.

Yet natural law never disappeared. After the Second World War, the trials of officials who claimed they were merely obeying the law revived the question of unjust laws. In 1980 the Oxford philosopher John Finnis published Natural Law and Natural Rights, a major restatement of the theory, which continues to influence legal and political philosophy.

Conclusion

From Antigone’s appeal to unwritten laws to Locke’s natural rights, the natural law tradition has insisted that power is subject to moral standards that reason can discover. Whether one accepts or rejects it, the debate between natural law and legal positivism remains central to questions of justice, human rights and political legitimacy. To continue, read our guide What Is the State?, our article on the state and civil society, and browse the political theory section. Arabic readers can consult our article on John Locke.

References

  • Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, I–II, qq. 90–97, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province, London: Burns, Oates & Washbourne, 1920.
  • Hugo Grotius, The Rights of War and Peace, ed. Richard Tuck, Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, 2005.
  • John Locke, Two Treatises of Government, ed. Peter Laslett, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988.
  • John Finnis, Natural Law and Natural Rights, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1980.
  • Knud Haakonssen, Natural Law and Moral Philosophy: From Grotius to the Scottish Enlightenment, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996.

Share this article

WhatsApp
Telegram
X
Facebook
LinkedIn
Enjoyed this article?Join 40K+ subscribers on YouTube and 20K+ followers on Facebook, where I explain these ideas and more on video (in Arabic).
Subscribe on YouTube
Follow me:
Picture of Mohammed Sultan

Mohammed Sultan

Political theory researcher and Latin America expert. He writes on political thought, civilizations and the critique of modernity, combining careful research with more than 13 years of creative and marketing experience.

Sultan's Monthly Letter

One selected article, my latest videos and readings in political theory and Latin America: one email a month, no spam.

Your email is safe. Unsubscribe anytime.

Related articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *