Skip to main content

Mohammed Sultan

Republicanism in Political Thought: Freedom as Non-Domination

When we hear the word “republic,” we often think simply of a state without a king. But in the history of political thought, republicanism is a rich tradition with its own ideas about freedom, citizenship and virtue. From Cicero in ancient Rome to Machiavelli in Renaissance Florence and the founders of modern constitutional states, republican thinkers asked how a free people can govern itself and avoid domination. This article explains the main ideas of the republican tradition and its revival in contemporary political theory.

In short: republicanism is a tradition of political thought that understands freedom as the absence of domination, meaning not being subject to the arbitrary will of another. It emphasizes the rule of law, mixed government with checks and balances, active citizenship and civic virtue. Its roots lie in ancient Rome (Cicero, Livy), it was revived by Renaissance thinkers such as Machiavelli, and it influenced the English, American and French revolutions. In recent decades, scholars such as Quentin Skinner and Philip Pettit have revived it as an alternative to liberalism.

Roman roots: res publica

The word “republic” comes from the Latin res publica, “the public thing” or “the affair of the people.” In his dialogue De re publica (On the Commonwealth), Marcus Tullius Cicero (106–43 BC) defined the commonwealth as the property of a people, where a people is not any gathering of individuals but an assembly united by agreement on law and by a shared interest. Following the Greek historian Polybius, Cicero praised the Roman constitution as a mixed government combining the strengths of monarchy (the consuls), aristocracy (the Senate) and democracy (the popular assemblies). The image illustrating this article, by Cesare Maccari (1880s), shows Cicero denouncing the conspirator Catiline in the Senate in 63 BC, a famous episode in defence of the republic.

Freedom as non-domination

At the heart of republicanism is a particular idea of freedom. In Roman law, the free person (liber) was contrasted with the slave (servus), who lived under the power of a master. A slave with a kind master might never be interfered with, yet he was still unfree, because he depended on another’s will. Republicans therefore understood freedom not merely as the absence of interference, but as the absence of domination: the condition of not being exposed to arbitrary power. Philip Pettit has made this distinction central to modern republican theory.

Idea of freedomDefinitionAssociated tradition
Non-interferenceNot being actively obstructed by othersClassical liberalism (Hobbes, Bentham, Berlin’s “negative liberty”)
Self-masteryGoverning oneself according to reason or true will“Positive liberty” traditions
Non-dominationNot being subject to the arbitrary will of anotherRepublicanism (Cicero, Machiavelli, Pettit, Skinner)

Machiavelli and Renaissance republicanism

In the Italian city-republics of the Renaissance, humanists such as Leonardo Bruni revived Roman ideals of civic life. The most important figure was Niccolò Machiavelli, whose Discourses on Livy studied the Roman republic. Machiavelli argued that well-ordered republics with good laws and armed, active citizens are more durable than principalities, and that conflict between the people and the nobility, if channelled through institutions, can protect liberty. J. G. A. Pocock called the moment when this tradition reappeared “the Machiavellian moment.”

Key republican ideas

  • Rule of law: a free people lives under laws, not under the arbitrary will of rulers. Republicans sought “an empire of laws, not of men,” in the phrase of James Harrington.
  • Mixed constitution and checks: power should be divided and balanced to prevent any person or group from dominating the rest.
  • Civic virtue: citizens must care about the common good and be willing to participate in public life.
  • Fear of corruption: republics decline when citizens prefer private interest and luxury over public duty.
  • Contestability: citizens should be able to challenge public decisions through institutions.

Republicanism in the modern revolutions

In seventeenth-century England, writers such as James Harrington (The Commonwealth of Oceana, 1656) and Algernon Sidney adapted republican ideas. In the eighteenth century, Montesquieu analysed republics in The Spirit of the Laws (1748), and Rousseau developed a demanding theory of popular sovereignty. Republican language shaped the American founders, who debated in the Federalist Papers how to build a large republic with checks and balances, and the French revolutionaries, who proclaimed the Republic in 1792. In Latin America, the new states born after independence also adopted republican constitutions.

The contemporary revival

From the 1970s, historians of political thought such as Pocock and Quentin Skinner recovered the republican tradition as distinct from liberalism. Skinner, in Liberty before Liberalism (1998), described a “neo-Roman” theory of freedom. Philip Pettit, in Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government (1997), developed freedom as non-domination into a full political theory. Today, republican ideas inform debates on workplace power, corruption, democratic accountability and the independence of public institutions. Critics ask whether republican virtue demands too much of citizens or whether non-domination differs significantly from liberal freedom.

Conclusion

Republicanism reminds us that freedom is not only about being left alone, but about living under laws and institutions that protect us from arbitrary power. It also reminds us that free institutions depend on citizens who care about the common good. To continue, read our articles on John Locke and natural rights, Aristotle’s Politics and browse the political theory section. Spanish readers can explore Maquiavelo y El príncipe.

References

  • Philip Pettit, Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997.
  • Quentin Skinner, Liberty before Liberalism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998.
  • J. G. A. Pocock, The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic Republican Tradition, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1975.
  • Cicero, On the Commonwealth and On the Laws, ed. James E. G. Zetzel, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999.
  • Maurizio Viroli, Republicanism, New York: Hill and Wang, 2002.

Share this article

WhatsApp
Telegram
X
Facebook
LinkedIn
Enjoyed this article?Join 40K+ subscribers on YouTube and 20K+ followers on Facebook, where I explain these ideas and more on video (in Arabic).
Subscribe on YouTube
Follow me:
Picture of Mohammed Sultan

Mohammed Sultan

Political theory researcher and Latin America expert. He writes on political thought, civilizations and the critique of modernity, combining careful research with more than 13 years of creative and marketing experience.

Sultan's Monthly Letter

One selected article, my latest videos and readings in political theory and Latin America: one email a month, no spam.

Your email is safe. Unsubscribe anytime.

Related articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *